Breach of Employment Agreements Ripe for Summary Judgment

Some employees enter into employment agreements that include the terms for severance and other benefits. In JIMMY L. HENSLEY V. COCKE FARMER’S COOPERATIVE, Mr. Hensley and Cocke Farmer’s Cooperative entered into a severance agreement in February of 2010 that stated Mr. Hensley would receive a certain amount of severance in certain circumstances, including termination without cause. This agreement was approved by the cooperative’s board. However, in 2010, in a move that should not come as a shock to any Tennessee lawyer who represents employee’s and workers, the Board moved to both RESEND the severance agreement and then to terminate Mr. Hensley’s employment contract without cause.

Both the employee’s laywer and the employer’s lawyers filed for summary judgment. The Trial Court found the agreement between the employee and the employer to be an enforceable contract, and found for summary judgement in favor of the employee Mr. Hensley, who is the plaintiff in the case. Farmer’s was ordered to pay Mr. Hensley $380,236.21 in accrued severance benefits plus pre-judgment interest (which is interest on the money that Mr. Hensley lost by not and potentially gained by Farmer’s while they withheld the funds). The Trial Court further ordered Farmer’s to pay Hensley $6,125 per month plus his premiums “for health insurance coverage equivalent to the . . . coverage in force for Jimmy Hensley immediately prior to his termination,” until August 12, 2024.


The Court of Appeals upheld the ruling and gave us the following quality tidbits:

  • “The co-op further asserts that the agreement fails for lack of sufficient
    consideration. The agreement provides for severance pay for Hensley, an employee of
    more than thirty-five years, who had been serving as a general manager for fourteen years
    at the time the agreement was executed. The severance pay was due in the event Hensley
    was terminated without cause. The agreement also provided that Hensley’s employment
    status remained “at-will.” The consideration provided by Hensley was his continuing
    employment with the co-op.” This is great caselaw to show consideration in employment contracts. Mr. Hensley could have gone elsewhere, and possibly made more money, and would have been enticed to remain at the Farmer Co-Op because of this severance provision. This has not been explicitly laid out yet in current Tennessee case law, and is very good for Employee’s lawyers.
  • On the issue of the damages being unreasonable: “In contrast, the recovery of severance pay is not conditioned upon a breach of contract or a reasonable estimation of damages. Generally, severance pay is a form of compensation paid by an employer to an employee at a time when the employment relationship is terminated through no fault of the employee. Black’s Law Dictionary 1374 (6th ed. 1990). The reason for severance pay is to offset the employee’s monetary losses attributable to the dismissal from employment and to recompense the employee for any period of time when he or she is out of work.”

Overall, this is a great case for Tennessee lawyers representing employee’s in employment law cases and severance agreements because it clearly lays out the law for us to use for motions for summary judgment on our own.

You can read the full opinion here:

Has your employer been giving you the run around on your severance package? Call Employee’s Lawyer Morgan Smith (615) 620-5848 we have experience negotiating severance agreements and litigating in both State and Federal Courts.

Similar Articles

Paid in Vacation Time? When I was working in government, it was very common to receive additional vacation time or sick leave for salaried employees who had to work excessive hours
What is Overtime? When people talk about overtime, what do they mean? In Tennessee, overtime is any work performed by a worker for an employer in excess of forty hours
Pre-shift work Many FLSA claims revolve around “pre-shift work” which is what we call the time people spend working before they get to go on the clock and be
Maracas ordered to pay $63,000 for wage violations Maracas, a local Mexican restaurant located here in Nashville is ordered to pay over $63,000 in damages for wage
Breach of Employment Agre... Some employees enter into employment agreements that include the terms for severance and other benefits. In JIMMY L. HENSLEY V. COCKE FARMER’S COOPERATIVE, Mr. Hensley and Cocke
Problems with unpaid labo... The food industry, especially restaurants with tight margins, are notorious for violating the FLSA and other wage and hour laws. You would think that since these companies
What to do when you are n... There are several quick tips you should follow if you are not being paid for all of your work.  Obviously, you should  immediately contact a wage and
Legal Updates Check out our posts with updates about employment law matters affecting Tennessee.  Recent posts are streaming to your right.
Some autoworkers are exem... xposted from Autoworkers may be exempt from FLSA (Fair Labor Standards Act) overtime pay requirements.  The FLSA is the law that requires companies to pay you
Picking a Lawyer How do you pick a lawyer for an unpaid overtime case? Look for someone you feel comfortable with and who has experience in your specific location and